Wildlife advocates say the state should prepare the public now for the possibility that mountain lions will be back in the future.
By Mike Lynch
Darcy Wiltse, a veterinarian, was driving on Route 458 near Meacham Lake one night early last winter when she saw a large animal crossing the road. She’s convinced it was a cougar.
“I saw the whole profile again. I saw the body. I saw the tail,” said Wiltse. “She even hesitated on the other side of the road before she went into the trees.”
Wiltse said this was the second time she’s seen a cougar in the Adirondacks. The first one was outside her house in Lake Placid about eight years ago in early winter. In that case, the cougar set off a motion-sensor light outside a window while it was eating bacon grease set out for birds. Wiltse watched the animal through a window with the aid of a flashlight.
“I literally went from the tip of her tail right up her whole body to her head,” Wiltse said. “Then she turned, looked right at me. Then she took off.”
The experience took about fifteen seconds. The animal left tracks, but by morning they were covered by snow. Wiltse, who holds two degrees from Cornell University, has been a veterinarian for thirty-one years and is confident that in both cases she saw a mountain lion.
“I know the difference between bobcat and mountain lion,” she said.
Her account is just one of seventeen “credible” sightings reported to Protect the Adirondacks from April 2013 through August 2014—the first eighteen months of the organization’s Cougar Watch initiative. “We continue to get several reports a month, and about half of those are hard to dispute,” said Peter Bauer, executive director of Protect. “They are adamant that what they saw was not a housecat and what they saw was not a fisher or any other type of long-tailed animals.”
Three sightings occurred within the same region within a relatively short period of time in 2014: east of Tupper Lake on June 4; east of Saranac Lake on July 12; and in Lake Clear on July 24. It’s possible, Bauer said, that different people were seeing the same animal.
Bauer said Protect deems accounts credible based on interviews. Also, the organization received photos of what are believed to be two sets of cougar tracks. So far, however, Cougar Watch has turned up no physical evidence of mountain lions roaming the Adirondack woods—no fur, no DNA samples, no photographs.
He said the animals could be wanderers from the Midwest or Canada. Cougars, especially young males, are known to travel hundreds of miles in search of mates and habitat.
State biologists say cougars vanished from New York State in the late 1800s as a result of predation by humans and the destruction of habitat, but many people insist that the big cats continue to live or at least pass through the Adirondack Park. Over the years, there have been hundreds of unsubstantiated sightings. The state Department of Environmental Conservation insists that most sightings are cases of mistaken identity and that any actual cougars observed are likely escaped or released pets.
DEC knows of only one wild cougar to have been in the state in recent decades: a young male was spotted in December 2010 in Lake George, where it left behind tracks and fur. It was killed by a car in Connecticut six months later. Scientists said it originated in the Black Hills of South Dakota and had traveled more than 1,500 miles.
Chris Spatz, president of the Cougar Rewilding Foundation, cast doubt on the sightings recorded by Protect, saying that physical evidence would be available if cougars were in the Adirondacks. He said mountain lions show up all the time in Midwestern states, where there is no evidence of breeding populations. They wander into towns and cities and “get hit, shot, snared, treed, wander in front of random remote cams.”
“Why not in the Dacks?” he asked.
He said his organization has conducted a decade of camera studies in seven eastern states, investigated fifteen years of sightings from Nova Scotia to Mississippi, looked at hundreds of solicited photographs, and found only one single confirmed cougar photo. That happened to be the same cougar that was killed in Connecticut.
“I wrote to Protect when they started the project that it was well-intentioned but doomed,” he said. “No one on the East Coast has gotten one piece of evidence from documenting sightings clusters. Not once. Their project will do nothing but perpetuate the fantasy of recovery, which is a huge distraction from what we should be discussing: restoring ecologically functioning populations of all the missing megafauna, including cougars, to the Adirondacks.”
Whether or not cougars exist in the Adirondacks, some wildlife advocates say the state should prepare the public for their possible return. Because the cougar population has been expanding out west, it may be just a matter of time before they reach the Adirondacks.
This past fall the Wildlife Conservation Society’s office in Saranac Lake released a report titled “Puma Concolor Cougar in the Adirondack Park: Resident and Visitor Perspectives.” The paper was authored by Heidi Kretser, who works for WCS, and Elizabeth McGovern, a master’s student at the Yale University School of Forestry and Environmental Studies.
“Cougars are potentially coming back.”
–Heidi Kretser, Wildlife Conservation Society
“One of the conclusions of the paper is that we think the state agencies and NGOs [non-governmental organizations] in the region should actually start to think about putting out brochures or public-service announcements about co-existing with cougars,” Kretser said. “Cougars are potentially coming back.”
McGovern surveyed 315 people in the Park, both residents and non-residents. Seventy percent of the residents and 84 percent of non-residents said they would not object if cougars returned to the Adirondacks on their own. In contrast, only 36 percent of residents and 40 percent of non-residents want the state to reintroduce the cats. Forty-four percent of residents and 58 percent of non-residents said state agencies should take action to facilitate their natural return. Only 23 percent of residents and non-residents surveyed said that the risks associated with living with mountain lions are well understood.
Gordon Batcheller, DEC’s chief wildlife biologist,thinks it’s premature to start preparing the public for the possible return of cougars. He said he wouldn’t be surprised if a breeding population established itself on Michigan’s Upper Peninsula in the near future, but the animal is probably decades away from recolonizing the Adirondacks. He added that suitable habitat likely exists in the northern forest stretching from New York to Maine.
“It’s not rocket science really to take a look at our landscape in the Northeast,” he said. “There’s a lot of habitat there, and an animal like the mountain lion could probably survive.”
If cougars were to return to northern New York, he said, they would tend to migrate to the Adirondack foothills and areas surrounding the Park where deer are plentiful. “The protein is not in the High Peaks,” he said. “The protein is in the periphery of Glens Falls and Plattsburgh.”
The last wild cougar in the Adirondacks (apart from the one in 2010) was killed in 1894 in Herkimer County. Now the closest cougars to the west may be in the Upper Peninsula of Michigan, although there’s no evidence of a breeding population. There’s also evidence that cougars are living northeast of the Adirondacks in Quebec and New Brunswick, according to the study “Genetic Confirmation of Cougars in Eastern Canada,” published in Northeastern Naturalist in 2013.
Between 2001 and 2012, researchers found nineteen positive identifications of cougars on thirty-eight scratch posts installed in national parks. Genetic testing revealed that some of the animals were from South America, suggesting they were released pets, but others originated in North America and could have been wild cougars from the West or from remnant populations in eastern Canada. Again, no evidence of a breeding population was found.
Cougars in the West faced the same hardships as those in the East when human settlers moved into their habitat.
But the populations in the West began to rebound in the 1960s and 1970s when they went from a species sought by bounty hunters to one protected by governments, according to the article “Cougars are Recolonizing the Midwest: Analysis of Cougar Confirmations During 1990-2008,” published in the Journal of Wildlife Management in 2012.
After the Black Hills population in South Dakota re-established itself in the 1990s, mountain lions recolonized the North Dakota Badlands and parts of Nebraska, according to the article. The authors found that the recolonization of the Midwest was taking place by “stepping-stone dispersers”—cougars that move from their place of origin to the nearest available habitat. In some cases, young males will travel greater distances.
John Davis, who heads the Wildlands Network’s Carnivore Recovery Program, said the cougar’s eastward migration has been slowed due to excessive hunting in Nebraska, South Dakota, and other states. In the Black Hills, fifty-three male and thirty-one female cougars were killed in 2014—out of a population of just a few hundred.
“The likelihood of cougars recolonizing [the Adirondacks] on their own is not very good in the near term because they are being heavily persecuted in the Midwest,” said Davis, who lives in Essex. “They are basically being blocked from moving north out of southern Florida, the other nearest population, by the Caloosahatchee Channel. So natural recolonization of cougars in the near term unfortunately is not very likely. In the longer term, it may be possible.”
But Davis is committed to studying whether cougars and other carnivores will be able to return to the Adirondacks naturally and to figuring out what needs to be done to help them do so. In November, Davis organized the Eastern Carnivore Summit in Lake Placid at the Intervale Lowlands Nature Preserve, private property owned by Larry Master, a former chief zoologist with the Nature Conservancy and an Explorer board member.
“It’s very clear we need to educate people clearly as wide as possible about the values of top carnivores—wolves, cougars, and lynx, in particular,” said Davis. “We need to show people these are not dangerous animals, and in fact they will make our forests healthier.”
Davis wants DEC to look at what can be done to help cougars, wolves, and lynx return to the Adirondacks, whether naturally or through a reintroduction. Besides public education, one idea is to improve and protect wildlife corridors that animals use to travel long distances.
Davis also would like to see these top carnivores included in DEC’s Wildlife Action Plan, the department’s guide to managing and conserving species and habitats. “To ignore them because they’re extirpated is a big mistake,” Davis said. “There’s a lot of science and research in recent decades showing that top carnivores are ecologically important.”
DEC’s Batcheller wouldn’t comment on the specifics of the Wildlife Action Plan, which was still being written, but he said the department has no plans to reintroduce cougars. He noted that a reintroduction would be costly and require the cooperation of neighboring states because the cats travel long distances.
“We just aren’t able to take this one on right now because it’s so huge,” he said. “We don’t have the capacity to deal with it, and it would take an awful lot of analysis and evaluation and public engagement before we even got out of the gate.”
Batcheller said DEC is monitoring the populations to the west and north and training staff to identify cougar sign and evaluate reports of sightings.
“Here’s the bottom line: if they come into New York and they become established, we’ll manage them as resident wildlife and, you know, learn what we can and manage them appropriately,” he said.
May 2013, North Elba: “My grandfather and I saw a Mountain Lion right across from the entrance to Meacham Lake campground on a Sunday morning in August of 1974 while driving from Saranac Lake to Malone. We got a very good look at it, it loped, not ran, over a hundred yards along the edge of the woods. 39 years later, about 2 am driving past the Cascade Inn, what I thought was a small dear jumped up in the middle of the road. I realized that it was not moving like a deer. I hit the brakes and almost stopped. It zig zagged, then stopped and turned and looked at me over its shoulder. The head and long tail were plainly visible. I called DEC in the morning and reported it. They said there had been no other sightings in the area. I stopped back the next day and looked for tracks, but it had been raining.”
July 30, 2013, Ray Brook: “At 6:30 pm driving between Saranac and Ray Brook on Route 86 I spotted a cougar crossing the road as I got closer to the DEC station. I saw another driver looking into the forest after it passed. I am familiar with the differences between lynx, bobcats, and cougars. It had big paws, a long tail and was the size of a Great Dane. It was very smooth in its movements.”
July 24, 2014, Lake Clear: “Went berry picking at night saw him he stalked us watched him for about 20 minutes snaking back and forth and backing away slowly never loosing eye contact with us.”
July 12, 2014, Saranac Lake: “Cougar ran across road (Rte. 3) from water’s edge just outside of Saranac Lake before Trudeau Sand & Gravel. It was light brown/light tan in color with a long tail (It was NOT a bobcat!!).”
June 4, 2014, east of Tupper Lake: “On Route 3 between Saranac Lake and Tupper Lake. Cougar crossed the road in a crouched manner, not running but moving quickly. Saw from behind again as we passed the point it crossed and saw in clearing from behind. Definitely a big cat, long tail, no spotting.”
August 3, 2014, Quaker Road, Queensbury: “My boyfriend and I were driving home from the drive in movies just after 1:00am, on Quaker Road in Queensbury, crossing the road near the pond area. I had to slow down to avoid hitting the Cougar. We both saw the cat in full light from my headlights no more than 20 feet in front of my car. The cat was about the size of a medium dog, and the tail was very long and definitely signature of a cougar.”
August 3, 2014, Silver Lake Mountain trail: “My wife and I both saw the cougar. It crossed the path west to east just past the entrance from the parking area but before the sign-in box. At first glance I thought it was a deer. I didn’t have a good look. However as we entered the path it crossed back from east to west. I had a very good look. It was the color of a yellow lab. I would guess it was about 100 lbs. Long tail, moved quickly and was clearly a very large cat. There is no doubt that it was a cougar not a dog, bear, deer or anything else. I spend a lot of time in the woods. I’ve seen bobcats, bears, deer, moose, fox, coyotes and other smaller mammals. This was large cat, long tail, yellowish color.”
To report a sighting, visit: protectadks.org/programs/report-a-cougar-sighting/
Well done, Mike. A couple of points.
As a member of the state wildlife action plan (SWAP) advisory committee, I helped draft the DEC’s cougar and wolf assessments for the SWAPs, which are now available for public comment. Though extirpated, both animals, with lynx, meet the federal criteria for Species of Greatest Conservation Need (SGCN). All three species have been dropped from the DEC’s SGCN list. Ask Mr. Batcheller why.
The DEC has developed guidelines for restoring extirpated species. The cougar meets the DEC’s two primary criteria of “analysis and evaluation” Mr. Batcheller describes: a peer-reveiwed Adirondack habitat analysis, published in 2013, and the 2014 WCS public attitude survey, which found that “a large percentage of people in this survey are interested in some form of human intervention in mountain lion restoration.” Yet, Mr. Batcheller continues to ply the smokescreen of a poor ADK prey-base for cougars, apparently, without citing any research on cougar predation and habitat use, while suggesting that cougars would be drawn to areas of higher deer-density and thus, closer to human populations and conflict: a veiled public-safety threat.
Vehicle collisions with deer kill 200, injure 20,000 and cause nearly $6 billion in damage annually in the US, a bigger public safety threat than all other wildlife combined. 70,000 deer are hit in NY State every year.
A cougar attack has not occurred in 25 years of Midwest dispersal. A cougar attack has not occurred east of the Rockies since the 1850s. Three people have been killed by cougars in the US since 1998 (none since 2008).
3,000 people have been killed and 300,000 have been injured by deer in the US since 1998.
The DEC should be relying on science and statistics in its discussion of cougar recovery, and stop playing the fear card.
Strange people think they don’t pass through. The one killed in CT was seen in the Lake George area 6 months before. That’s not really far away… So say it was just six months (doubtful) – that meant there was a lot of hanging out in the same geographic region… Meaning to say – it doesn’t take 6 months to go from Lake George to Connecticut. There should have been a lot of pictures then – but there weren’t. It was healthy when it died – so what was it eating? If there “has to” be evidence of kills – well no one seems to know where those kills were. I guess they really are that elusive then.
Plus the DEC would have simply said it was someone’s escaped pet – had it not been killed in CT.
Philip Coltart says
I saw a big cat. Long tail, but Lynx features. I walked up to it thinking it was a large fox. It was about a 70lb cat. No doubt whatsoever. It shocked me. July 2014 kings road, Corinth.
Funny how I saw one lying, still in the road after being hit by a car. on the Taconic State Parkway, in the town of Stanfordville, Dutchess Co. Both NYSP and DEC were there to collect the carcass. Was may be 2009.
John Palmer says
What about the mountain lion pets, can they breed and eventually become wild again ?
John Palmer says
We need a governor who’s a real outdoorsman and wants to bring back Elk, Wolves and Mountain lion.
Brett Allen says
Thought the readers may enjoy this… there are Mt Lions in the foothills of the Adirondacks already; just as ENCon predicted… of course I spoke to a Game Warden friend years ago would told me of one being killed by a car near the the lake. The Great Sacandaga Lake has had many sightings and a spate right after this article was published… http://www.sacandagaexpress.com/news/08232012_cats
Kathleen Moulton says
About 10 years ago I saw a mountain lion on our property – Stockholm, St. Lawrence County. I heard it before I saw it. It was pacing along the tree line and meadow.
There was no confusion. The tail was long.
bILL kENNICK says
ON 1/22/2018 in Greenwood lake NY, I was visiting a friend on Mountain View road. I saw a large cat at a distance of 100 feet. It was maybe 3 times bigger than my 2 ordinary fat house cats whom I regularly see roaming the woods around my house. So I have a basis of comparison. This cat was tan and ordinarily shaped like a trim house cat. It had a long tail, tan, but with 3, maybe 4 black rings around it at the tip. Like a racoon tail but just at the tip and not furry. Nothing about this cat was furry. It was a lean cat. No big head, nothing like that . Proportioned like a house cat but very big and the striped tipped tail. Seen at noon to 12:30 PM in the woods at the end of Mountain View road. Temperature was a warm 45 degrees and it was not raining,. A little snow remained from last weeks snowfall but very little. The cat was nosing around taking its good old time moving across the landscape. My friend did not see it when I tried to point it out to her.