Nearly one in three residents in New York’s 21st Congressional District rely on Medicaid, making it a crucial part of the healthcare system
By Tim Rowland
Nearly one in three people in the North Country are direct beneficiaries of Medicaid, but even that doesn’t cover the extent to which communities depend on the 59-year-old government health program.
Should Medicaid be scaled back, clinics and nursing homes that depend on government reimbursements for the care they provide to financially disadvantaged people would suffer, possibly to the point of extinction, said Dr. John Rugge, founder of the Hudson Headquarters Health Network. If these institutions are lost, he said, the Adirondacks will become a health care desert where, for example, a young woman going into labor would face hours of drive time getting to a city hospital.
The Adirondack Explorer thanks its advertising partners. Become one of them.
“In this North Country region, almost everything, every part of the health delivery system, is in danger — in danger of either having services contracted or sometimes just failing and disappearing,” he said.
To that end, Rugge and other physicians and community leaders have formed the Healthcare Coalition for the North Country, a nonpartisan advocacy group designed to protect Medicaid and the people who depend on it. The coalition, which was formally announced at dual press conferences in Albany and Lake George Wednesday, has already attracted 170 members, with many more expressing interest.
“What we’re concerned about is creating awareness on a nonpartisan basis of what the implications are of change, and what the role of Medicaid is for all of us,” Rugge said.
Although the situation is fluid, House Republicans are searching for $880 billion to help pay for tax cuts proposed by Pres. Donald Trump. The nonpartisan Congressional Budget office estimates cuts, as most recently proposed, would cost 8.7 million people coverage over 10 years.
The Adirondack Explorer thanks its advertising partners. Become one of them.
“A great deal is at stake for local hospitals, nursing homes, and medical practices—in fact, the whole healthcare system—if there are quick, careless cuts to Medicaid,” the coalition wrote in announcing the press conferences.
Along with caring for lower-income people, Medicaid also provides nutrition and health care for children and covers 60% of nursing home residents. The coalition said Medicaid supports 215,000 of the 772,000 residents in New York’s 21st Congressional District. Under GOP budget plans, 55,000 of those residents would lose coverage. Many others are likely to receive substandard care at an ultimately higher cost. “(Patients) will delay care, be sicker when they do seek care, use emergency rooms more frequently, and be hospitalized more frequently and be more likely to die,” coalition founders wrote. “They will have unpaid medical bills and be more likely to go into bankruptcy.”
Rugge, who founded Hudson Headwaters in 1974 to combat the shortage of rural care, said the nonpartisan HCNC is not looking for political scraps, and acknowledges there are parts of Medicaid — and American health care in general — that need work.
But he hopes lawmakers will not cut blindly without considering the consequences. This message has resonated with the grass-roots recruitment the coalition has taken to date. “So one of the most astonishing things to me was just coming across people in the line to the movies, in the shopping center, at the grocery store, and hearing how many people were saying, ‘Oh, Medicaid, yeah, that is so important to us in this community,” he said.
Medicaid cuts could seriously impact the economy as well, Rugge said, where healthcare is one of the top employers. According to the state Department of Labor, more than 18,000 people work in the industry in the North County. Between 3,200 and 5,200 of these jobs could be lost if health care facilities are no longer viable, according to the Medicaid coalition.
The Adirondack Explorer thanks its advertising partners. Become one of them.
Beyond that, businesses will not want to locate in an area with a paucity of health care and even second-homeowners, especially those who are older, might have second thoughts about making the Adirondacks a destination, Rugge said. Medicaid itself is complicated, and neither it nor the effects of wholesale cuts are easily understood.
If changes to Medicaid are made, “it can’t be with a big sweep of the hand,” he said.”It has to be carefully designed and in keeping fiscal responsibility, patient responsibility, caregiving and all the rest —we need to be very, very careful so no harm is done to individual people, the economy and healthcare as a whole.”
HCNC will spread its message by making presentations for public officials, the news media and other interested parties, as well as collecting patient stories to help show the need for Medicaid both with data but also through human experience.
Those wishing to join the coalition can visit https://www.northcountrymedicaid.org/join-us
The Adirondack Explorer thanks its advertising partners. Become one of them.
Photo at top: The Healthcare Coalition of the North Country, led by Dr. John Rugge, founder of Hudson Headwaters, discuss potential Medicaid cuts and how they would affect the North Country in a press conference Wednesday at the state capitol. Photo by Lori VanBuren, Times Union
Where is our Rep. Elise Stefanik? What is she doing to address these likely Medicaid cuts that will hurt her own constituents? Or will she just ignore the damage that will likely result as she parrots Republican talking points?
She does not care. She is a big supporter of Trump. This policy is on purpose. The tax cuts are only for the rich… they’re robbing Peter to pay Paul. Look at this chaos. This administration is only looking to help their rich friends, and is scamming the rest of the world with crypto. They don’t care if people are sick. Sick people are too tired to fight back. This is only the beginning. They want to weaken our country and send us into a new Civil War. That is their goal.
According to a poll by KFF from March, 42 percent of adults want Congress to increase Medicaid funding, and 40 percent want the funding to remain the same. What’s interesting is that 22 percent of Trump voters want Medicaid funding increased, and 43 percent want the funding to remain the same.
That’s pretty strong bipartisan support for the Medicaid program,
She will do whatever she thinks her president wants her to do; she is not in this game to serve her constituents. That said, there is apparently an overabundance of MAGA voters in her district who consistently vote against their own best interests, so I don’t think she feels the need to consider their best interests when they don’t.
The majority of the north country residents voted for Trump and Project 2025. Were you not paying attention to the MAGA cult’s plan to make us great again? Enjoy the fruits of your vote.
The sky is falling, the sky is falling. OMG here we go again with all you naysayers.
There are a number of Republicans who oppose the proposed cuts to Medicaid:
“The plan is also facing Republican opposition in the Senate. Senators Rand Paul of Kentucky and Ron Johnson of Wisconsin have said the current bill is fiscally irresponsible. Senator Susan Collins of Maine has said she opposes at least one Medicaid provision in the legislation. And Senator Josh Hawley of Missouri described the bill’s changes to the government health program for the poor as a nonstarter, saying they amounted to “taxing the poor to give to the rich.” (NYT)
Are they ‘naysayers’ too?
Hey George, just so you know, Medicaid is the foundation upon which our North Country behavioral health system is built. It is one of the finest in the country and I feel confident saying the best rural system in the nation. You may not notice, because that’s the point. If it went away, trust me, you’d notice. Any reduction in medicaid eligibility or reimbursement rates would definitely, immediately, result in layoffs and the shuttering of services and programs.
Excellent article! It speaks to just how critical Medicaid is to healthcare and life in the North Country. Representative Stefanik has not spoken in support of Medicaid for NY 21, and she failed respond to attempts to contact her regarding the Coalition’s mission.
Waste and fraud and theft of taxpayer monies is what is being identified and removed. The idea of the program being dismantled is absurd. This is nothing more than scare tactics 101 by the Democrats, who want nothing but the status quo spending, waste and theft to continue.
What was that again?
https://www.wsj.com/politics/policy/trump-doge-government-spending-increases-5903992d?mod=hp_lead_pos7
Waste and theft of what? By whom? Do you have any knowledge of how the medicaid system works and who/what it supports? Do you have any factual information regarding what is being proposed and what is not? Do you have any factual information to support your assertion whatsoever? If so, please share. I’ll not be holding my breath….
Scare tactics by Democrats? I guess someone forgot to tell Republican Senators Rand Paul of Kentucky, Ron Johnson of Wisconsin, Susan Collins of Maine, and Josh Hawley of Missouri, all of whom are either against the cuts as proposed or are opposed to parts of the funding reduction that they’re engaged in Democrats’ “scare tactics.”
This administration does not care about the citizens of the United States. This is happening so rich people can get a tax cut. It is immoral. Look at the chaos, and this is only the beginning. Congrats to all the people that voted for this group, scamming the world with crypto, accepting bribes. This is a travesty and many people will become sick when Medicaid cuts come though. Sick people are too tired to fight back. I think that’s what they want.
This is what Republicans want to cut:
“Poor adults who gained Medicaid coverage after the Affordable Care Act expanded access were 21 percent less likely to die during a given year than those not enrolled, the research shows. By analyzing federal records on 37 million Americans, two economists found that deaths fell not only among older enrollees but also among those in their 20s and 30s — a group often assumed to have few medical needs, and who would have been far less likely to qualify for Medicaid before the expansion. The findings were published this month in a National Bureau of Economic Research working paper, as House Republicans were drafting a plan that could significantly cut Medicaid, which covers 71 million low-income or disabled Americans.” (NYT)
So 55,000 of us North Country residents will be out , left to be sick and have to cure ourselves or die, or maybe go bankrupt and be out on the street , with our families ,only to get sick and die there after the Emergency rooms stop accepting patients that probably won’t be able to Pay . Big Pharma ,bigGovt ,big Health care , takeing care of the people that Covid didn’t ? Are they ? Should be real nice here in the North Country , Hopefully this holds up until winter ,when we all can do some Winter Camping out in the streets and woods of our past homes and towns , So this is what we have to look forward to, when’s the date to start with the mass panic , with all the Doom and Gloom speech we’re hearing, guess it’ll be any day now . Of course we can all stop listening to the news media and just live life as we always have and carry on the best we can ,without all the Political Hate messages bombarding us….